The Cayman Islands boast several excellent Italian restaurants that cater to diverse palates. Whether you’re craving a casual family-friendly meal or an upscale dining experience, the Cayman restaurant scene here has something to offer everyone. From Georgetown to Seven Mile Beach, you’ll find restaurants offering authentic Italian dishes that bring a taste of Italy right to your table. No matter where you are in Grand Cayman, a delicious Italian feast is always nearby, ready to transport you straight to the Mediterranean with each bite of pasta or perfectly crisp pizza Margherita.
Let’s explore some of the best Italian eateries on the island. Prepare to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the top Italian restaurants the Cayman Islands have to offer. Whether you’re travelling from Northside or West Bay, there’s an excellent ristorante for you! Get ready to satisfy your Italian cravings in the Caribbean!
The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta: Italian Food You’re Craving
Located on the Crescent in Camana Bay, with a view of the vibrant fountains, The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta is a firm favourite for fans of pizza & pasta dishes alike. Many name Brooklyn the best Italian restaurant on the island for a casual, friendly and of course delicious dining experience. One of their standout dishes is the seafood linguini, a perfect blend of mussels, shrimp, and salmon tossed with al dente linguine in a garlic white wine sauce. The restaurant also offers several pizza options, and there’s nothing quite like a fresh pizza margherita. For something a little different, try the shrimp scampi pizza or the sweet and savoury orchard pizza, topped with pear and prosciutto.
For more traditional fare, the spaghetti & meatballs is a comforting classic that hits all the right notes. Pair your meal with an aperol spritz or a glass of Italian wine from the extensive wine list for a full Italian dining experience. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza or pasta, The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta has a range of flavours that will satisfy any craving. If you’re a family looking for the best Italian restaurant for ragazzi then Brooklyn’s your best bet. Kids love the laid-back atmosphere, big comfortable sofas on the Camana Bay Crescent, and of course, the exceptional pizza & pasta.
Bonfire Urban Kitchen: Craft Your Own Pizza Adventure
At Bonfire Urban Kitchen, you can truly get creative with your food. Their unique concept lets you build your own pizza, allowing you to choose from a wide variety of toppings, sauces, and cheeses, all provided by Bonfire’s authentic Italian kitchen. Go classic with pepperoni, sausage, and peppers, or opt for something more adventurous like jerk chicken or shiitake mushrooms. Each pizza is wood-fired to perfection, giving it a beautiful crispy crust.
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, there are also hearty rice dishes and pasta options, along with fresh salads and beautifully grilled fish. Bonfire Urban Kitchen is perfect for a fun, interactive dining experience where you can tailor each dish to your tastes.
Guy Harvey’s Boathouse: Seafood by the Sea
For a more seafood-focused experience, head to Guy Harvey’s Boathouse. Situated on the waterfront, this restaurant offers picturesque views along with delicious Italian-inspired seafood dishes. One of their most popular items is the seafood penne, featuring shrimp, scallops, calamari, and mussels in a rich tomato cream sauce. Each bite is a perfect fusion of seafood and pasta, making it a must-try for anyone visiting.
If you prefer rice dishes, the Maine lobster risotto is a wonderful alternative. It comes with roasted pumpkin, basil, cherry tomatoes, and parmesan cheese, offering a creamy, flavorful combination that will make your taste buds sing. The relaxed, seaside ambiance only enhances the dining experience, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely meal.
Saltwater Grill: A Medley of Fresh Pasta
Located on West Bay Road, Saltwater Grill is well known for its delicious, elevated Italian cuisine. Close to the Ritz Carlton & Camana Bay, Saltwater Grill is in an easy-to-reach location. Whether you’re setting out for brunch, lunch or dinner, Saltwater Grill meets every Italian taste requirement. For families or groups looking for something everyone will love, Saltwater Grill offers a wide variety of pasta dishes, all made with the freshest ingredients. The shrimp linguini is one of their signature dishes, made with succulent shrimp, garlic, white wine, arugula, chilli flakes, and cherry tomatoes, served with al dente linguine. Each bite bursts with the flavours of Italy. For a traditional entree, their penne all vodka is a great choice. An american twist on an Italian classic, the penne is always perfectly al dente and the sauce, perfectly creamy.
Vegetarians will love the garden vegetable linguine, featuring local callaloo, asparagus, peas, and zucchini. This dish highlights the fresh, vibrant produce of the island while staying true to Italian cooking traditions. For younger diners, the penne pasta with marinara sauce is a comforting and familiar option. Saltwater Grill is an excellent choice for an authentic Italian meal that pleases both adults and children.
The White Whale: A Local Favourite
Although it’s not an Italian restaurant, The White Whale is loved by locals for its traditional Italian food offerings. Known for its comforting and flavorful Italian classics, The White Whale is a cherished spot among locals & visitors. With stunning Caribbean Sea views, its location on the Georgetown waterfront makes the experience truly special. One of their standout dishes is the creamy mushroom alfredo, which takes a simple pasta dish and transforms it into something special. The dish features sautéed mushrooms, red onions, and spinach, all wrapped in a rich, velvety alfredo sauce. Add chicken, shrimp, or salmon to elevate this dish even further. With each bite, you’ll feel transported to Italy, enjoying a hearty, comforting meal.
Whether you’re craving a classic spaghetti dish, creamy pasta, or a slice of pizza, The White Whale has you covered. The perfect combination of fresh ingredients and indulgent flavours will leave you more than satisfied.
No matter your tastes, the Cayman Islands offer a variety of Italian-inspired dining experiences that are sure to please any palate. From traditional pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, and even seafood and rice specialties, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion in Grand Cayman or simply enjoying a casual meal, the authentic flavours of Italy are never far away.Download the Bite Club app from Google Play or the App Store, and start earning Bite Club Points with each visit to any of these outstanding restaurants. With every visit to these top restaurants, you can earn Bite Club Points that can be redeemed for future meals. Whether you’re enjoying a bowl of spaghetti, a freshly made pizza, or a seafood risotto, every bite brings you closer to exclusive rewards. Start earning today and enjoy all the best Italian food the Cayman Islands have to offer!
