Canadian Thanksgiving, celebrated this year on October 14, 2024, is a time for reflection and gratitude. For many Canadians living abroad, especially in sunny Grand Cayman, it’s an opportunity to gather with loved ones and enjoy a traditional feast of turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, and all the comforting sides that make the holiday so special. Grand Cayman’s vibrant restaurant scene embraces this North American tradition, offering hearty Thanksgiving meals at several top establishments in the Caribbean.
Before diving into the list of Grand Cayman’s best Thanksgiving destinations, it’s worth understanding why this celebration extends beyond Canadian borders. Canadian Thanksgiving has been celebrated on the second Monday of October since 1957, although its roots go back centuries. The holiday stems from harvest festivals held in European traditions and was also influenced by Indigenous celebrations of giving thanks for a successful harvest season. Today, it’s a day for Canadians to express gratitude, share meals, and enjoy time with family and friends.
In the Cayman Islands, with its large expat community, Canadian Thanksgiving has found a place among the island’s many cultural celebrations. Several restaurants in Cayman Islands mark the occasion by offering traditional Thanksgiving meals, bringing a taste of home to Canadians spending the holiday abroad. Supermarkets also offer traditional Thanksgiving dinner items but no one wants to fight the crowds in the deli line on Thanksgiving! Whether you live in East End or are staying at the Kimpton, if you’re craving turkey and all the trimmings, here are the best restaurants to celebrate Canadian Thanksgiving in Grand Cayman.
1. Duke’s Seafood and Rib Shack
Location: Seven Mile Beach
Price: $17.95
Duke’s Seafood & Rib Shack is a popular spot for both locals and tourists, known for its laid-back vibe and mouth-watering BBQ dishes. Not far from West Bay, on a lively beach facing corner of West Bay Road, Duke’s is in the perfect location to enjoy comforting holiday favourites in a casual atmosphere. For Canadian Thanksgiving, Duke’s serves a traditional Thanksgiving dinner complete with savoury turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, and seasonal sides. Duke’s offers a great value at only $17.95, making it one of the more affordable places on the island for your turkey feast.
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Affordable feast: At $17.95, Duke’s offers a budget-friendly option for a full Thanksgiving meal.
- Casual, family-friendly atmosphere: The laid-back, outdoor setting is perfect for families or groups of friends looking to enjoy Thanksgiving in a relaxed, island-style environment. Sometimes you just don’t feel like fine dining!
- Location: Duke’s is located along Seven Mile Beach, close to hotels like the Kimpton and the Ritz-Carlton, and just a short drive from West Bay or Georgetown.
2. The Waterfront Urban Diner
Location: Camana Bay
Price: $17.95
The Waterfront Urban Diner, nestled in the lively Camana Bay, is known for its fusion of comfort food with modern, fresh flavours. For Canadian Thanksgiving, The Waterfront offers a traditional turkey dinner with all the fixings at the same affordable price of $17.95. The restaurant’s stylish yet casual setting, paired with its beautiful waterfront views, makes it a lovely spot for a Thanksgiving celebration. Waterfront’s a la carte menu is also available on October 14. If you’re not feeling like turkey, don’t miss out on scrumptious options like the Indian curry or fish tacos.
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Affordable and scenic: The combination of a reasonably priced Thanksgiving meal and stunning views of the water make this a must-visit spot.
- Family-friendly environment: The Waterfront’s casual, welcoming atmosphere makes it ideal for family gatherings.
- Convenient location in Camana Bay: Enjoy a Thanksgiving dinner and then take a post-meal stroll around the beautifully lit Camana Bay Harbour.
3. Lone Star Bar & Grill
Location: Seven Mile Beach
Price: $17.95
Lone Star Bar & Grill is a beloved institution on Seven Mile Beach, known for its Tex-Mex cuisine and lively sports bar atmosphere. While it’s typically the go-to spot for burgers, ribs, and Mexican fajitas, Lone Star steps into the Thanksgiving spirit with a traditional turkey dinner at just $17.95. For expats and tourists looking to watch sport while enjoying a turkey feast, Lone Star offers a comfortable and lively setting. You’ve had enough french fries, indulge in some creamy mashed potatoes this visit!
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Affordable price: Like Duke’s & Waterfront, Lone Star offers a delicious Thanksgiving dinner for under $20.
- Lively sports bar atmosphere: With plenty of screens showing Canadian and American sports, it’s a great spot to catch Thanksgiving games while indulging in your turkey feast.
- Perfect for groups: Lone Star’s spacious interior and casual vibe make it a fantastic choice for group celebrations.
4. Craft F&B Co.
Location: Seven Mile Beach
Price: $19
Craft F&B Co. is known for its elevated yet comforting fare and trendy, chic environment. For Canadian Thanksgiving, Craft is serving up a traditional turkey dinner with all the trimmings for $19. The restaurant’s focus on fresh, local ingredients and creative presentations make it an exciting choice for those looking to enjoy a slightly elevated version of the classic Thanksgiving meal. Craft’s stylish and modern interior makes it a popular spot for young professionals and families alike. Ask about a beer or wine pairing for your meal to perfect the experience. P.S. If you don’t make it for Thanksgiving, come back at the weekend for Craft’s incredible Saturday & Sunday brunch.
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Chic, modern environment: If you’re looking for a trendy spot to celebrate Thanksgiving, Craft’s elevated atmosphere is ideal.
- Fresh, local ingredients: Craft’s commitment to using fresh, seasonal ingredients ensures that your Thanksgiving meal is both delicious and thoughtfully prepared.
- Great for groups: Craft’s lively environment and large dining space make it perfect for group dinners. Come for happy hour, stay for your traditional Thanksgiving dinner!
5. The White Whale Pub & Ale House
Location: George Town
Price: $19
The White Whale Pub & Ale House is a favourite in Grand Cayman’s dining scene, loved for its warm, pub-style atmosphere and wide selection of drinks. For Canadian Thanksgiving, The White Whale is offering a traditional turkey dinner for $19, making it a great option for those who love the idea of celebrating Thanksgiving in a comfortable setting. With hearty portions and a welcoming vibe, The White Whale offers a homely experience perfect for Thanksgiving.
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Cosy pub atmosphere: If you prefer a casual setting for your holiday meal, The White Whale offers a warm and inviting environment right on the waterfront.
- Great selection of drinks: Pair your Thanksgiving meal with one of The White Whale’s excellent beers or ales for the perfect pub-style holiday celebration.
- Central location: Conveniently located in George Town, The White Whale is a great option for those wanting to celebrate Thanksgiving in the heart of the island.
6. Boathouse Grill
Location: George Town Harbour
Price: $19
The Boathouse Grill, located on the George Town Harbour, offers one of the best waterfront dining experiences for local food in Grand Cayman. Known for its Caribbean-inspired dishes and fresh seafood, Boathouse Grill is joining in the Canadian Thanksgiving celebrations with a traditional turkey dinner for $19. The restaurant’s stunning views of the harbour and its fine dining atmosphere make it an ideal spot for a wonderful holiday meal. Ask your server for the ideal wine pairing to complete the experience!
Why it’s perfect for Thanksgiving:
- Scenic waterfront location: Boathouse Grill’s beautiful harbour views provide the perfect backdrop for a memorable Thanksgiving meal.
- Fresh, Caribbean flavours: While the focus for Thanksgiving will be on traditional dishes like turkey and mashed potatoes, Boathouse Grill’s dedication to fresh, locally sourced ingredients ensures a delicious and high-quality feast. If you’re not in the mood for turkey, sample their Italian pasta or delicious local seafood from the a la carte menu.
- Great for families and groups: With its spacious dining area and friendly staff, Boathouse Grill is an excellent choice for a family-friendly Thanksgiving celebration.
While Canadian Thanksgiving is primarily celebrated in Canada, it has gained popularity in other parts of the world, especially in places like the Cayman Islands where there is a significant expat community. Many Canadians live and work in Grand Cayman, and the island’s restaurant scene has adapted to embrace the holiday. The Cayman Islands welcome all culinary cultures to the fold. If you’re an American who can’t wait for American Thanksgiving, the Canadian holiday is an opportunity to share in celebrations even earlier.
Canadian Thanksgiving provides expats with a comforting taste of home while allowing others to experience this North American tradition. In addition to its cultural significance, Thanksgiving holidays also mark the beginning of the cooler season in the Cayman Islands, making it an ideal time for outdoor dining and celebrations.
Whether you’re a Canadian expat living in the Cayman Islands or a visitor to the Caribbean looking to partake in the holiday festivities, these six restaurants offer the best Canadian Thanksgiving meals on the island. From affordable turkey dinners at Duke’s, The Waterfront, and Lone Star, to slightly more upscale feasts at Craft, The White Whale, and Boathouse Grill, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. And with the option to order delivery through Let’s Eat, you can even enjoy a delicious Thanksgiving meal from the comfort of your own home without the hassle of takeout.
Make your reservations early, and enjoy a wonderful Canadian Thanksgiving in the beautiful Cayman Islands.