The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta is an American-style Italian restaurant in Grand Cayman, on the Crescent in Camana Bay. It serves brick-oven pizza, pasta, salads, sandwiches and mains, with a kids menu and a shaded patio overlooking the water. It’s also a Bite Club partner, so a meal there earns points.
That makes it the easy answer when the group chat has agreed on Italian and nobody can agree on anything else. The pizza fans get their pizza, and the smallest critic at the table gets a menu of their own.
What’s on the menu at Brooklyn
The menu has eight sections: bruschetta, starters, salads, sandwiches and fries, pizza, mains, pasta and a kids menu. That’s a lot of ground for a restaurant with “pizza” in its name, and you can browse through delicious items at Brooklyn’s Bite Club listing.
The pizzas worth looking past the pepperoni for
The classics are all there, Margherita and pepperoni included. The Fun Guy piles portobello, button and shiitake mushrooms onto a parmesan cream sauce with truffle oil, and the Orchard pairs poached pear and prosciutto with gorgonzola and a drizzle of truffle honey.
Every pizza comes out of a brick oven, and Camana Bay’s own listing calls them “globally inspired”. Fair enough, when one borrows its shaved beef and provolone from a Philly cheesesteak and another arrives topped with shrimp scampi.
Pasta, mains and the fritters
Spaghetti and meatballs and carbonara cover the comfort end of the pasta list. Then there’s a coconut curry penne with shrimp and Thai red curry, which is the kind of dish that wins over the friend who claimed they weren’t hungry.
Mains lean hearty, with braised lamb shank on polenta and grilled salmon with asparagus. The signature starter is the Mac & Cheese Fritters: three-cheese macaroni, fried, and served over marinara with fresh basil.
Gluten-free and family-friendly options
Gluten-free diners can swap in a gluten-free pizza crust or gluten-free pasta, both listed on the menu.
The kids menu has a 6-inch pizza, chicken tenders and fries, and a build-your-own pasta where children choose the noodle and the sauce.
How to dine in, book or order delivery from The Brooklyn
Brooklyn opens at 11:30am and stays open until 10pm from Sunday to Thursday, and until 11pm on Friday and Saturday. You can book a table through Bite Club, and on a clear evening the patio over the water is the seat to ask for.
For nights on the sofa, The Brooklyn delivers through the Let’s Eat app.
Two regular offers are worth knowing about. The express lunch runs Monday to Friday and pairs a 6-inch pizza with a Caesar or house salad. On Thursdays from 5pm, Pasta & Wine night means build-your-own bottomless pasta, plus a pasta and soda deal for kids aged 12 and under.
Dinner and a film in Camana Bay
Brooklyn is a short walk from the Camana Bay Cinema, the only movie theatre in the Cayman Islands. An early pizza before a film is about as easy as an evening out gets on the island.
If you’d like more options nearby, the Camana Bay restaurant guide covers the rest of the waterfront. For midweek plans further afield, there’s our weeknight dining guide, and the Bite Club restaurant directory lists every dine-in and delivery partner.
The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta: common questions
Where is The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta in Grand Cayman?
On the Crescent in Camana Bay, at 47 Forum Lane, with indoor seating and a shaded patio overlooking the water.
Does The Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta deliver?
Yes. Delivery runs through the Let’s Eat app.
Does Brooklyn have gluten-free options?
Yes. Gluten-free pizza crust and gluten-free pasta are both available as substitutes.
Is Brooklyn good for children?
Yes. There’s a dedicated kids menu with a 6-inch pizza, chicken tenders and a build-your-own pasta. The Camana Bay fountains nearby and within view also offer great entertainment for kids if waiting for food is just too much.